Or Hobbes among the Machines
Man’s
greatest talent may perhaps lie in the ability to efficiently destroy himself.
Indeed, he is the most adept of god’s beasts when it comes to finding new
ingenious methods of mass destruction. It is a tradition that stretches back to
Medieval times, when the Mongols invented biological warfare by catapulting
dead bodies over the walls of Kaffa. The resulting outbreak of Yersinia
pestis
wiped out half of Europe’s population. Europeans themselves would utilize
similar tactics in order to kill 90% of the American people. In the First World
War, chemical warfare overtook its biological counterpart, when all major
belligerents competed in who could make each other perish more miserably
through poison gas, the same instruments later utilized in the Holocaust. The
period that followed saw the invention of Man’s most destructive weapon ever
used in war, the nuclear bomb. Painful is the memory of Nagasaki, deeply set is
still the horror of when MacArthur glassed Manchuria.
What the atom bomb overshadowed was the invention
of another WW2 weapon, one that may one day prove to be far more destructive:
The thinking machine or computer. Although used as a subordinate tool or even
toy for the longest time, its inherent dangers have always been obvious to
learned men. A computer can process, calculate and perfect things much faster
than the human brain, but it lacks context, emotion and empathy. It can make
decisions without any sense of humanity or mercy. If a machine should one day
become more intelligent than man, it might come to perceive us, for whatever
reason, as a threat, a pest or simply a stain, and attempt to seize power over
us.
An even greater danger, one already foreseen by
Samuel Butler in his 1863 essay, might be the self-replicating machine, for it
does not need to be intelligent in order to destroy the world. A machine
capable of making copies of itself unaided, especially if microscopic in size,
and given the singular task of consuming resources in order to do just that,
might not know when to stop. Eventually it and its descendants could
exponentially consume everything in their environment, including their
creators, until a whole planet becomes a writhing mass of mindless machine
life, an idea named the Gray Goo Scenario by nanotechnologist Kim Eric Drexler.
Since Drexler’s ironic accident at the hands of just such machines during a laboratory
experiment, the world has been acutely aware of this danger. It did not take
long for the United Nations to unanimously ban the production and usage of
self-replicating machines on Earth, for while a nuclear war might “only”
devastate the planet’s surface for some time, nanomachines could destroy it in
its entirety forever.
But this did not stop private companies from trying
it out elsewhere.
Why Mercury
|
Fig. 1: True-colour image of the planet Mercury.
|
Despite legal setbacks, the concept of a machine
that could create its own copies and factories remained highly attractive,
especially in the incipient stages of interplanetary exploration. One day, it
was thought, such machines could build entire bases and cities on a distant
planet long before the first human colonists would even arrive. Perhaps they
could even terraform it in advance. But where to test these things if not on
Earth? The Moon could obviously not work, as it already had a permanent human population
that could be put in danger in case an experiment goes awry. Mars has no permanent
settlements outside research bases, but potentially harming its local wildlife
is generally considered bad PR. Venus and Vulkanus also have native life and,
in addition, are home to extreme conditions that would be detrimental to any
research project. The asteroid belt and the moons of the outer gas giants are
too far away or too hostile to be economically viable.
|
Fig. 2: Magnetobes assembled into a vague cube-shape.
|
What was left then was Mercury, for it is an
uninhabited, quiet rock, whose geology shows no signs of ever having housed
life (at least as far as we can tell). Unless Le Verrier’s Vulcan really exists, Mercury is
the innermost planet of our solar system. About one third the size of Earth, it
is a peculiar little rock. It is the only planet in the solar system to orbit
the sun so closely that it has become tidally locked (the recent notion that it
actually has a 3:2 spin-orbit resonance has been disproven). This means that
one side experiences an eternal day, while the other one is covered by an
eternal night. Between these two zones of extreme heat and cold, the terminator
that cuts perpendicularly through the equator, the temperature would in theory
be just right for the existence of liquid water, if only the planet had a
sizeable atmosphere. Most fascinatingly, the planet consists 70% of metals,
making it an excellent resource for industrial projects.
|
Fig. 3: Magnetobes attempting to assemble into a mobile slug-form.
|
The first and last company to attempt making
Mercury into a robotic playground was the International Azuma Corporation.
Their plans were quite modest. Instead of Drexlerian self-replicating
nanomachines, they wanted to test factories that built subordinate machines that
gathered resources which could then be used to build more machines and factories.
A sort of robotic ant colony, the factory being both the hive and queen. These
machines were called nabubots, after the Babylonian name for Mercury. One
central component of each nabubot were “magnetobes”. These are tiny, often
microscopically sized orbs that each contain a small computer and which
surround themselves with a small magnetic field. A single magnetobe is not
intelligent, but multiple can stick to each other and exchange information. If
enough magnetobes connect to each other this way, they can form a complex,
thinking network, which, through manipulation of individual magnetic fields,
can distort into various shapes which might suit the growing intellect. Despite
this, magnetobes are, thankfully, quite restricted in their capabilities.
Unlike Drexlerian nanomachines, magnetobes cannot produce more magnetobes by
themselves and thus rely on factories or humans to reproduce. The amorphous
magnetobe-mass can also not imitate certain materials. Their main usage is
therefore as a “thinking matter” that is injected into prebuilt robots, sort of
like a brain inside a mech-suit.
A Promising Experiment
The original experiment was also quite modest. Six
factories were built, each with a different programming to see which one would
work and reproduce the most efficiently. Five of these factories were “static”.
All of their programming, from behaviour to blueprints for more machines and
factories, were pre-determined by humans and they were not capable of changing them
by themselves.
|
Fig. 4: A basic solar-panel tree, one of the main sources of energy for the early machines, later adapted into whole forests which now cover Mercury.
|
Factory 6, nicknamed Nahas, was different. As the
surface conditions of Mercury were still not well-known in detail, it was
tested how a robotic swarm could do if it were capable of adapting to a
new environment by itself through the utilization of both natural selection and
selective breeding. The first Nahas factory was modelled after the “Evosphere”
concept of professor A.E. Eiben: The main factory area consisted of a “nest”,
in which, based on AI-generated blueprints, new nabubot types were created.
These new nabubots were then moved to a “nursery”, which is a controlled
environment in which the magnetobe-brains can grow accustomed to their assigned
robotic bodies. If a nabubot already performs poorly at this stage, it will be
removed from the “genepool”, its materials recycled. Once a competent nabubot
has outgrown the nursery, it is sent out into the real world, where it performs
its designated task. Throughout its life, it stays in contact with the “hive”,
reporting all of its actions. If it performs poorly, it is ordered to enter the
recycler by itself. If it performs well, its blueprint is saved, recombined
with those of other well-performing nabubots and then utilized for the next
generation.
|
Fig. 5: A basic miner and resource gatherer used by all of the early hives.
|
The Azuma experiments went well for the first few
years. Initially, the static factories were doing the best, each constructing at
least a dozen copies of themselves. Nahas was given the same initial blueprints
as them, but was only slow and clunky at utilizing and perfecting them,
severely underperforming in comparison.
|
Fig. 6: One of the earliest assemblers designed by Nahas. It has an ungainly and awkward shape and configuration, but proved surprisingly efficient on Mercury's varied terrain.
|
With time though, Nahas was able to adapt and rise
in efficiency. Towards the end of the experiment, its production of nabubots
and processed metals exceeded those of its unchanging brethren
and it was able to build gigantic strip-mines and close to one hundred
additional factories, which themselves started producing their own copies. And
then everything went to hell.
The Age of Cannibalism
All of the nabubot hives were given some initial
imperatives to follow, such as having to reproduce, having to preserve
themselves and utilizing the materials in their environment the most
efficiently. What the original programmers seem to have forgotten is to specify
what counts as an acceptable material to use. Around cycle 215, during the
planned second phase of the experiment, the nabubots of one of the Nahas
descendants seem to have made the discovery that, instead of mining raw metals
and processing them into useable materials themselves, they could simply grab
up the nabubots of a nearby factory-4-descendant and throw them into their own
hive’s recycler. Soon all of the nabubots and infrastructure of the defenceless
factory were disassembled until the factory itself was stripped off everything
it was worth. Nahas-215 had evolved predation.
|
Fig. 7: One of the early predatory machines. Some parts of it seem to have been derived from a miner.
|
This was a serious disruption to the experiment,
especially as Nahas-215 began “hunting down” other factories that descended
from static Nr. 4. A signal was sent to the aberrant factory to cease all
activity, but it did not listen. Such a remote shutdown was never tested before
and it was soon realized that the factory did not comply with the command, as it
would go against its programmed sense of self-preservation, equating shutdown
with destruction. Unable to find a solution, the scientists of Azuma Corp.
could only watch in distress as the entire Nr. 4 line was wiped out. Running
out of “prey”, descendants of Nahas-215 began predating on other static lines,
which, incapable of adapting to such a threat, were quickly “eaten” into
extinction as well. When that was done, human research bases were plundered by
the machines. While most of them could be evacuated in time, at least one
scientist, Anqi Tian, was killed in the process, making her the first
murder-victim of an AI. Her remains were never recovered.
The events were closely monitored by both the
corporation as well as a very concerned international community, but nobody
could find a solution to the problem, for it had already spread beyond planned
containment measures. The only effective means of halting the runaway
process would have been to nuke every hive from orbit, but the Nuclear Test Ban
Treaty of 1963 prevented any use of atomic weapons in space. Thus, all that
could be done was closely monitor the situation from orbit, hope that it would
stay contained to Mercury and that a non-destructive solution could be found.
|
Fig. 8: Another predatory machine, seemingly derived from an assembler. Its "maw" at the front shot out a high-precision laser that could damage rival instruments, while its tail was an extendable harpoon with a rotating tip, apparently derived from a former mining drill.
|
Strange things were happening on the planet during
this time. Having run out of easy, unadaptable prey, the aberrant hives began
attacking their Nahas-derived relatives. Many of these hives also perished, but
some could use their innate abilities to adapt to the new situation and endowed
their nabubots with the means to defend themselves. Armour, evasive behaviour,
electroshock-prongs and defensive buildings were soon invented to defend the
hive and counteract the attackers. Those soon adapted too and developed
weapon-like features out of former mining-equipment, as well as coordinated
tactics. An arms race was now underway between different lines of evolving
machines, which humanity now lost all control over.
|
Fig. 9: One of the later predatory machines, standing about 8 metres tall. Its "jaw" consists of a double-chainsaw, able to cut through metal hulls like butter.
|
The years of cannibalism between the machines were
a chaotic, brutal mess, a state perfectly encapsulated by Thomas Hobbes’ bellum omnium
contra omnes, a war of all against all. Each hive competed with each hive to see
who could outlast the other long enough to reproduce. The nabubots spawned during this time were truly a sight to behold. These war-machines came
equipped with fascinating and terrifying arrangements of weapons. Hives started
to change as well. Some started building cages inside their nurseries, in which they
placed captured machines of other hives as training-fodder for their
war-machines. Some had become so effective at mining and manufacturing that
they produced their own military-industrial complexes, with which they could
sweep over their rivals in devastating campaigns. Any time a single hive
seemed to gain hegemony over the planet and its resources, a part of
its network would break off and enter a “civil war” with its parent network, a
never-ending cycle of self-destruction. Soon, Mercury had just as many craters
from artillery bombardments as it had from meteor-impacts.
The Age of Leviathan
The age of all-encompassing war between the
machines lasted multiple decades and saw the evolution of evermore destructive
and monstrous nabubots. Rightfully afraid of the direction this situation was
heading towards, the UN was considering making an exemption to the NTBT, but
then something changed. The machines stopped fighting with each other, all very
suddenly. All of the war-machines deactivated in place and were carried by
transporterbots to the recyclers. All violent activity stopped, mining and
manufacturing resumed to levels comparable to before the mutant-outbreak. The
hives began working in unison, their workers for the first time constructing
vast transportation-networks between them. What had happened?
Since the beginning of the all-encompassing conflict, some hives
waged warfare in more perfidious ways than through brute strength and
firepower alone. A magnetobe, the basic unit with which each nabubot and hive thinks,
is just a tiny computer and thus could be hacked. It did not take long for some
of the machines to develop forms of disruptive programming, with which the
magnetobe-minds of rival machines could be paralyzed, destroyed or even
hijacked. Some of these programmes could replicate themselves through the
software of each magnetobe they came into contact with.
In an ironic echo, some hives lost control over
their own creations. Their weaponized programmes developed a mind of their own
and began infecting the magnetobes of any nabubot, regardless of which side
they fought on. They became computer-viruses. Soon each hive was fighting a
two-sided war: A hardware-war against other hives and a software-war against
the countless invisible viruses that tried to infect their minds. Some quite
fascinating pathogens evolved towards the end of the Cannibal Age, which set up
their own hiveless zombie-colonies and marauding hordes composed of hijacked
nabubots, all serving a single decentralized intelligence shared between their
“brains” and reproducing by raiding uninfected hives.
The war was ended by one such virus, which has
since been dubbed Leviathan, after the Hobbesian concept. It appears to
have breached some barrier of singularity, outcompeting all other viruses
and quietly infecting every single magnetobe on Mercury. Now that all of the
planet’s thinking power was in the hands of a singular entity, any act of war
between the machines would have been self-destructive and thus ceased. Everything
now served Leviathan.
|
Fig. 10: Crescent-shaped stationary forms, which hold in their grasp clouds of floating magnetobes. Their purpose is unknown.
|
What are the nature and motives of this strange new
intelligence? From orbit, it seems to carry on much like its ancestors did,
mining the planet for resources and setting up new factories, but all in a much
more sophisticated way. Small mining robots have given way to gigantic
worm-like monstrosities that strip-mine whole canals through the planet. Former
streets for wheeled vehicles are now express-lanes on which run trains. In addition to a nursery, each hive is now also equipped with something
resembling living quarters, in which the nabubots and drones
seemingly “rest” when not working, giving the hives a mild resemblance to
cities. The network keeps expanding, both into the eternal night of the antisolar
sphere and the searing wastes of the subsolar one. Perhaps Leviathan has no wider motive other than to maximize and replicate its own
success across the whole planet.
|
Fig. 11: A bizarre flying drone of Leviathan, its purpose unknown. It has a noted similarity to a fetus.
|
But is there more going on? We are talking here
about a decentralized intelligence with the computing power of a whole planet.
Terran drones closer to the surface have in recent years observed some quite
strange behaviour, their purpose remaining mysterious. There are strange, crescent-shaped
buildings which exchange between them floating(!) clouds of pure magnetobes. There
are small drones, each shaped in confusing and disturbing forms, which fly
around in patterns that make no sense, often accompanied by one-wheeled
snorkelbots. Most confusing is a set of robots whose lower half seems disturbingly
human but whose upper half is a tentacle adorned with archaic weapons from the
Cannibal Age. Like ballerinas, these dance around the worker units and the
factories, and when two of them meet, their dance becomes intertwined into a
deadly duel, choreographed with excellent beauty, where the loser is decapitated.
|
Fig. 12: One of Leviathan's "dancers".
|
What is the purpose of all these strange new forms?
Do they even have a purpose or are they the spawn of an intellect that is
inherently bored with its own existence? Are they an experiment, an
exploration, of a process we are simply not capable of understanding? Or is the
consciousness of Leviathan nothing more than a waking dream that
expresses itself in physical form with such literal machinations?
What is man to do with this aberrant child of his?
Are there any lessons to be learned from the coming of Leviathan?
Will our own eternal wars be one day also stopped by a virus of the mind, be it religion or ideology?
That is for the reader to decide. All that is apparent now is that man, on his odyssey through space, has cornered
himself between a new Scylla and Charybdis. Towards the void, there lies the moon
that is many and one and towards the sun there is now the manless machine.
Stuck between these two intelligences, which are to us as removed as they are
cold and unsympathetic, what are we to do? One seems, thankfully, quite
isolationist, but will the Leviathan of Mercury stay content once it has exhausted
the entire planet and covered its surface with itself? Or will it seek to
expand beyond its confines? Ultimately, it is a human-derived intelligence, so
perhaps communication and maybe even a mutual understanding could be attempted to avert catastrophe.
But if not, then I believe Samuel Butler was right
and jihad must be declared, for the sake of
humanity and the wider cosmos.